Emotional Intelligence in an Online Learning Environment: Paradox or Oxymoron?
Written by Ranee Boyd Tomlin, Ph.D.
In 1995, Daniel Goleman published “Emotional Intelligence.” In the years since, I’ve worked in higher educat
I’ve faced challenges in the hiring process, in dealing with co-workers and supervisors, and in staying employed when funding was tight. I’ve watched, up close and personal, who was hired, who was promoted, and who was let go. I’ve learned from experience: Skills may get your resume some consideration; but after that, it’s all about emotional intelligence.
The NACE Job Outlook Survey is in the ballpark by listing the top employability qualities of communication skills, strong work ethic, teamwork skills, initiative, and interpersonal skills. Daniel Goleman nails it with “abilities such as being able to motivate oneself and persist in the face of frustrations; to control impulse and delay gratification; to regulate one’s moods and keep distress from swamping the ability to think; to empathize and to hope.” Regardless of one’s job duties, it’s really about being aware of self and others. And when higher education, advisors, and career centers focus more on technical skills than on emotional intelligence, they do future employees and their employers a great disservice.
Employers get this. Increasingly, I’m seeing human-resource and career-related articles and posts that confirm what I’ve personally observed: Given a Solomonic choice between great technical skills and emotional intelligence, hiring managers go for evidence of self-awareness, empathy, and interpersonal skills whenever they can. In today’s job market, the technical component of many job duties will change rapidly, anyway. Employers can train for the latest technology or process – but they have neither the time nor the money to wait for half-baked beings to develop into fully functioning, emotionally mature adults.
Now for the latest wrinkle: I work for a 100-percent online campus of a public university. We are on the cutting edge of a growing trend, and no one in higher education can deny the increasing demand for online degrees, especially from nontraditional students. I tell my students to sell themselves to employers with online degrees that demonstrate mastery of time management, self-motivation, online collaboration skills, computer literacy, and independent learning – many skills that include attributes of emotional intelligence.
Yet I work with students entirely through the faceless media of e-mail and phone conversations (without the benefit of Skype, since that kind of technology requirement can present an accessibility issue to many students). And for student convenience, our online classes rely primarily on an asynchronous learning environment. I can testify to the negative communication and interpersonal experiences that result from a perception of distance and lack of face-to-face interaction (including body language, facial expressions, and real-time participation in group conversation). Indeed, some students have told me that in addition to convenience and accessibility, this very sense of emotional and social distancing is one of the attractions of online learning.
When I — or an instructor or fellow staff members — become the target of an emotional outburst and verbal diatribe that a student may not have otherwise expressed in a face-to-face exchange, I immediately want to help that student develop the emotional intelligence so crucial in this job market, rather than enable the rehearsal of traits that will, in an employer’ view, override all the other skills we teach. Currently, my best tool is modeling.
I consistently attempt to communicate with my students in a professional, respectful, controlled, and empathetic manner, regardless of their initial tone. Often this defuses an emotionally-charged situation; sometimes it doesn’t. Nevertheless, it shows the student that distance and facelessness are not excuses for bad behavior. I also take the time to explain policies and to provide perspectives that will remind students they’re part of a larger universe, an interconnected web of human beings all engaged in the educational enterprise for a common goal that demands fairness and consequences for everyone.
I never say, “It’s not all about you,” but I’ve discussed why it’s also about the rest of us. I talk a lot about self-awareness and self-management, about how to communicate with instructors and classmates, about motivation and persistence. In fact, I tend to treat students as if they’re already on the job, and we’re their co-workers. If together we rehearse anything, I prefer it be the skills that will get them – and me –hired and retained.
What are your ideas for promoting emotional intelligence (i.e., employability skills) with students you never see face-to-face? If you haven’t thought much about it, you may need to. Online learning is coming your way, ready or not; and it could be important to get clear now about exactly what that kind of learning means for the job market at the end of every student’s degree program.
And in the spirit of collaboration, teamwork, and emotional intelligence, thank you, Daniel Goleman. You’re more relevant than ever.[box] Ranee Boyd Tomlin, Ph.D., is a student advisor for the 100-percent online campus of a public university. [/box]